Pittsburgh, PA
The Legal Intelligencer
(by Michael Korns and Anna Jewart)
Pennsylvania municipalities are empowered not only to adopt ordinances and enforce them but to establish fines and penalties for violations of the same. However, municipalities are creatures of statute and authorized only to act within the bounds of the powers granted to them by the General Assembly. The various municipal enabling statutes, such as the First Class Township Code, as well as other statutes such as the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code, all include express authorizations for municipalities to prescribe fines and penalties for violations of municipal ordinances and also establish restrictions on the upper limits of those fines or civil penalties per violation. Typically, these statutes also expressly establish that a municipality may, by ordinance, provide that a separate violation shall arise for each day of violation and for each applicable section of the ordinance. Consequently, municipalities, generally, are permitted to seek cumulative fines which grow each day a violation persists. Both the Pennsylvania State Constitution, article I, section 13, PA. CONST. art. I §13, and the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution, U.S. CONST. amend. VIII, (as made applicable to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment, U.S. CONST. amend. XIV) prohibit excessive fines, providing in relevant part that “[e]xcessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed…” On April 2, 2025, the Commonwealth Court explored whether a cumulative municipal fine imposed under the Philadelphia Code, as authorized by the First Class City Home Rule Act, 53 P.S. §13101 et seq., was unconstitutionally excessive.
In City of Philadelphia v. Epstein, No. 515 C.D. 2024, 2025 WL 981892 (Pa. Cmwlth. April 2, 2025)[1] the Court reviewed the outcome of a longstanding enforcement action by the City of Philadelphia originating from a 2018 enforcement notice and 2019 complaint seeking a permanent injunction and fines regarding violations of the City Code. …